The Double-Edged Sword Named "Google Reviews"

JUST FOR YOU
A Story

Fake Google reviews threatened to turn Eliza’s dream into a nightmare. 

Her Whistling Kettle cafe was a local favorite. She poured her heart into her business and her baking. 

Yet the cafe had an alarming number of negative Google reviews.

She read through some and found them vague, lacking anything about her cafe or the food.

Eliza was furious! 

She poured over the reviews to deduce whether they were real or fake. Perhaps something from either a competitor or a vengeful previous customer? 

She needed more positive reviews, and quickly sent texts and emails to her long-time customers, asking them to leave reviews. 

She documented each suspicious review, noting the lack of detail, the timing, and flagged them for Google to review.

Each day in the cafe, Eliza went from table to table asking for feedback and ways for improvements.

She set out comment cards for patrons to leave handwritten notes about their visits.

Mike, a long-time customer and influencer, decided to feature the Whistling Kettle on his YouTube channel. 

His post quickly went viral and flooded the cafe with new customers.

Weeks passed and real customer reviews surpassed—and even hid—the fake reviews. 

The cafe’s ranking climbed back to the top spot and Google reviewed and removed some of the fake reviews.

The Whistling Kettle thrived and became resilient against underhanded tactics that small businesses sometimes face. 

With the help of her community, Eliza overcame the negative reviews and her cafe grew.

INSPIRATION BEHIND THE STORY
Google Reviews and Your Church

Inspiration for the story above and the summary below can be found here.

Churches can apply these techniques to manage their online reputation and address negative or fake reviews:

1. Monitor Reviews: Churches should regularly monitor their Google reviews to identify negative or fake feedback.

2. Genuine Reviews: Encourage members and visitors to leave genuine reviews about their experiences. A higher volume of positive reviews can help offset the impact of negative or fake ones.

3. Identify Fakes: Look for signs of fake reviews, such as vague language, overly positive or negative sentiment, and patterns in timing or language.

4. Respond Publicly: Respond to all reviews, including negative and fake ones, professionally and respectfully. This shows that the church values feedback and is committed to addressing concerns.

5. Inappropriate Reviews: If a review is identified as fake or violates Google's guidelines (e.g., offensive content, spam, impersonation), flag it for removal.

6. Follow Up: Keep track of the status of flagged reviews and follow up with Google if necessary.

This took 2 hours to write. 😃 Thank you for taking 10 seconds to share.

P.S. Did you miss the last newsletter? Catch up right here with Digital Marketing and Your Church Growth